The 23rd

The 23rd is the first Christmas episode of the 2011 FOX sitcom starring  as Jessica "Jess" Day, a quirky, oddball twenty-something teacher who moves in with three men after breaking up with her cheating ex-boyfriend(Ian Wolterstorff).

Plot
Jess and her friends attends Schmidt's holiday office party and Jess frets when she receives an expensive gift from her boyfriend Paul(Justin Long), because he also tells her he loves her, and she may not necessarily reciprocate those feelings.