'Twas the Night Before Christmas, You're Under Arrest

"'Twas the Night Before Christmas, You're Under Arrest" is the second Christmas episode of the 1960s sitcom , starring as Ann Marie.

Synopsis
After Ann buys theater tickets for the Baumans from a scalper, Donald teaches her about a scam where customers are robbed while they are at the show. Realizing that she may have fallen for the scam, Ann and Donald remove their Christmas presents from their apartments and are mistaken for burglars by a neighbor who calls the police.

Trivia

 * The episode was written by Ruth Brooks Flippen. Her late husband Jay C. Flippen plays Sergeant Fitzgerald in this episode.
 * The title is a pun on the Clement Clarke Moore poem "A Visit from St. Nicholas."